Collecting

Grade a Record on the Goldmine Scale in 7 Steps: Light, Play Test, Sleeve and Seller Notes

How to turn a scuff, a click and a split seam into an honest VG+ or VG

Stylish indoor scene featuring a desk lamp, record player, wooden table, and ladder against a neutral backdrop.

Illustration: a record, as a placeholder for the cover photo.

The Goldmine scale is the standard used by Discogs, eBay record sellers and most dealers. It has eight grades: Mint (M), Near Mint (NM or M-), Very Good Plus (VG+), Very Good (VG), Good Plus (G+), Good (G), Fair (F) and Poor (P). The scale only works if the grader applies it the same way every time. The method below is for grading your own copies, whether you are listing duplicates, cataloguing for insurance or recording condition in your Discogs collection.

Goldmine grades and rough value relative to Near Mint
Grade What it means for the vinyl Approx. value vs NM
M Unplayed, flawless. Rarely justified, even for sealed copies Above NM
NM Glossy, no visible wear, plays silent apart from inherent pressing noise 100%
VG+ Light scuffs or hairlines visible under light, no effect on play ~50%
VG Surface noise audible in quiet passages, groove wear starting ~25%
G+ / G Continuous noise, plays through without skipping 10–15%
F / P Skips, cracks, deep scratches, severe warp 0–5%

1. Clean before you grade

Dust and fingerprints add crackle that is not damage. Give the record a wet clean, or at least a carbon-fibre brush pass, before judging anything. A dirty VG+ grades as VG on the play test; a clean one may come back as NM.

2. Inspect under a single bright point of light

Ceiling lights and daylight hide marks. Use one desk lamp or an LED torch and tilt the record slowly through every angle, side A then side B.

  1. Look for hairlines: fine, shallow marks that catch the light but cannot be felt. Usually VG+.
  2. Look for scuffs: dull patches where the gloss is gone, often from sliding in a paper sleeve. Light ones are VG+; heavy ones push towards VG.
  3. Run a fingernail gently across any line that looks deep. If the nail catches, expect a click on playback.
  4. Check for groove wear: a greyish, dull sheen on the loudest passages, caused by worn styli or heavy tonearms. This is a VG mark even if nothing is scratched.
  5. Lay the record on a flat table and look across the edge for warps or dish.

3. Play-test the quiet parts

Visual grading alone does not hold up. Hairlines that look bad often play silent, and a clean-looking record can hiss from groove wear. Play the lead-in groove, the first and last thirty seconds of each side, and any quiet passage: a ballad intro, a fade-out, the space between tracks. Note every click by its track number and timing. Inner tracks distort first, so give the final track on each side extra attention.

4. Grade the vinyl by its worst flaw

A record is not averaged. One scratch that clicks fourteen times through a track caps the grade at VG or below, even if the rest is pristine. Decide the media grade from the most serious defect you found, then move on.

5. Grade the sleeve separately

Sleeve and vinyl get their own grades, written as Media/Sleeve, for example VG+/VG. Check for:

  1. Ring wear: a circular rub from the disc inside. Light ring wear makes a sleeve VG+; ring wear that has removed print makes it VG or lower.
  2. Seam splits: measure them. "2 cm split on bottom seam" is useful; "some seam wear" is not.
  3. Writing, stickers, tape and stamped promo marks.
  4. Cut-outs: drill holes, saw cuts or clipped corners from deleted stock. Always mention them, because many collectors avoid them.
  5. Spine fading and corner dings.

Labels count with the media grade. Writing or stickers on a label should be noted even if the vinyl is clean.

6. Write notes a buyer can check

Grades are shorthand; notes make them credible. A good note reads: "VG+/VG. Light hairlines side A, play silent. One faint click 1:12 into B2. Sleeve has moderate ring wear and a 3 cm split on top seam. Original inner sleeve included." Include whether the original inner sleeve, insert or poster is present. These items often change the price more than half a grade does.

7. Grade down when in doubt

If you hesitate between VG+ and NM, choose VG+. Most Discogs disputes come from records graded one step too high. A buyer who receives a copy better than described leaves good feedback. A buyer who receives one worse than described opens a case.

Grade the record before you look up its sales history on Discogs. Once you know a VG+ copy sells for £80 and a VG for £35, your eye starts finding reasons to round up. Write the grade and notes first, then check the price.

Dexter "Deck" Miller

80s New Wave & Cassette Enthusiast

Dexter is the resident expert on all things 1980s, from neon-lit synth-pop to the quirky resurgence of cassette tape physical media. He reviews classic synth-driven albums, gives advice on vintage tape deck maintenance, and analyzes the golden era of MTV-era physical formats.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share your experience.

Leave a comment

Comments are published after moderation.

The Weekly Groove

Get new records in your inbox

New guides, tips on finding vinyl, and one album breakdown every week. No spam.