Spot a Counterfeit Record in 7 Checks: Labels, Run-Outs, Cover Print and Price
How to catch a fake Blue Note, Northern Soul 45 or sealed 'original' before it costs you real money

Illustration: a record, as a placeholder for the cover photo.
Counterfeits cluster where the money is. That means rare Blue Note and Prestige jazz, Northern Soul 45s, early Beatles and Dylan, psych and private-press rarities, and anything sold as "sealed original." A fake Frank Wilson "Do I Love You (Indeed I Do)" on Soul 35019 costs pennies to press. A real one costs more than a car. Run these checks before you pay serious money for any record.
The 7 Checks
-
Look at the label print under a loupe. Original labels were typeset and printed by offset or letterpress. Text is crisp and the ink sits evenly. Most counterfeit labels are reproduced from scans, so look for soft edges on small type, blotchy solid colours, dot patterns in areas that should be flat colour, and logos that look slightly bloated. Check the details forgers miss. Early Blue Note labels carry the New York address: 767 Lexington Ave, later 47 West 63rd. A deep groove pressing has an indented ring pressed into the label itself. If the ring is printed rather than physically pressed, walk away.
-
Match the run-out against a known genuine copy. Pull up the release on Discogs and compare every character in the dead wax. That includes matrix numbers, stamper codes, plant marks, and engineer stamps like Rudy Van Gelder's "RVG" or the Plastylite "P" (the "ear") on Blue Notes. Fakes often have a hand-etched matrix where the original was machine-stamped, or the other way round. Others have the right numbers in the wrong handwriting, or no plant mark at all. A blank run-out on a record that should have one is a strong warning sign.
-
Examine the cover for scan artefacts. A cover reproduced from a scan loses sharpness, especially in fine text on the back. Look for moiré patterns in photographs and colours that are too saturated or washed out. Construction matters too:
- Many 1960s UK sleeves were "flipback" covers, with laminated fronts and folded flaps glued on the back.
- Many US sleeves of the same era had a paper slick pasted onto board.
- A modern one-piece printed jacket on a supposed 1962 pressing is wrong.
Check the spine as well. Counterfeits often get the font or catalogue number placement slightly off.
-
Check for anachronisms. Barcodes didn't appear on LP jackets until the late 1970s. A barcode on a "1968 original" means it's a reissue at best. Other giveaways include coloured vinyl that was never officially issued, a "180g" hype sticker, or a heavy pressing claimed as a 1960s US release when most of those were thinner. Look for copyright lines naming companies that didn't exist yet, and website or email addresses anywhere on the package.
-
Be sceptical of anything sealed and rare. Shrink-wrap can be applied by anyone with a heat gun. A sealed copy of a record that is scarce even used should prompt questions, not excitement. Ask the seller why they can describe the pressing in such detail without opening it. If the listing won't show the run-out, you can't verify it, so price it as unverified.
-
Listen if you can. Counterfeits are frequently mastered from a vinyl rip or a CD. A vinyl source leaves faint clicks and surface noise that sit in the same place every play, because they are baked into the cut. A CD source sounds compressed and flat next to a period lathe cut. If the seller offers a needle-drop clip, compare it with a known original.
-
Read the seller, not just the record. Warning signs include:
- Multiple copies of the same rarity in stock
- A price well below market with no explanation
- Stock photos instead of photos of the actual copy
- Vague answers about where the record came from
On Discogs, check the seller's feedback for comments like "not as described" or "reissue." A genuine dealer will photograph the label, cover and run-out on request without complaint.
| Record / category | Common fake | Key tell |
|---|---|---|
| Blue Note 1500 series | Re-pressed "originals" | Deep groove indent, "ear" in run-out, label address |
| Northern Soul 45s | Bootleg presses of rare titles | Label print quality, run-out style vs known copies |
| Early Beatles (Parlophone, Vee-Jay) | Vee-Jay counterfeits | Label colours, logo artwork, matrix stamping |
| Bob Dylan, The Freewheelin' (1963) | Fake "withdrawn tracks" copies | Matrix number must match the withdrawn issue |
| Private-press psych | Unofficial reissues sold as originals | Cover stock, scan blur, missing plant marks |
Bootleg, Unofficial Reissue or Fake?
These terms describe different things, and the difference affects value:
- Bootleg: previously unreleased material, such as a live tape or studio outtakes.
- Unofficial reissue: a copy of a released album, sold openly as a reissue and not as an original. Some EU budget labels, such as Waxtime and DOL, have issued older jazz titles under public-domain claims.
- Counterfeit: a copy made to pass as the genuine article.
None of the three is worth original money, but only the counterfeit is designed to fool you.
Before you go buying for a specific record, photograph or save a verified copy's label, back cover and run-out from Discogs. Comparing side by side on your phone in the shop is far more reliable than relying on memory, especially for small details like font weight in the catalogue number.






Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your experience.